Skip to main content
All Digests

Psychology

·

Jun 1, 1983 – Sep 1, 2019

Same light, same tunnel: why near-death experiences look alike

No spamNo marketingOnly data
ES

Evgeny Smirnov

8 papers in this digest · 4 Must Read · 1983–2019

Last updated Nov 18, 2026

Introduction

Some people who survive a close brush with death later describe leaving their body, a tunnel or darkness, a brilliant light, meeting the dead and a deep sense of peace, and many say the experience changed them for years. Raymond Moody gave this a name in 1975, the near-death experience, and the accounts turn out to be remarkably alike (though not identical: Kellehear (1993) argues the tunnel and the life review are culture-bound, and Martial et al. (2017) show the order of features varies from person to person).

This is not a digest of fresh papers. It is a short path through one question that the name quietly answers in advance: do you actually have to be close to death to have one?

Greyson (1983) gave the field its measuring stick, a 16-item scale with 7 points as the usual threshold, and almost everything below uses it. Then came the prospective cardiac studies. Van Lommel and colleagues (2001) followed 344 resuscitated patients in ten Dutch hospitals: 18% reported an NDE, and whether they did was not linked to how long the cardiac arrest or the unconsciousness lasted. Their reading: if anoxia alone were the cause, most clinically dead patients should report one. Greyson (2003) went further with 1,595 cardiac inpatients. NDEs followed 10% of cardiac arrests and 1% of other admissions, yet experiencers and matched controls did not differ in objective proximity to death.

Then the Liège group turned the question around. Charland-Verville and colleagues (2014) compared 140 NDEs after coma with 50 "NDE-like" experiences after events that were not life-threatening, and on the Greyson scale the two were indistinguishable. Martial et al. (2018) found that the NDE-like group, not the classical one, scored higher on fantasy proneness. Cassol et al. (2019) showed that in both groups the NDE becomes a memory that defines the person, and that what matters is how rich the experience was, not its circumstances.

If dying is not the trigger, what is? Two candidates. Timmermann et al. (2018) gave DMT to 13 healthy volunteers under placebo control and got experiences that overlap with real NDEs on nearly every feature. Kondziella et al. (2019), in a crowdsourced sample of 1,034 people, found NDEs more often among those reporting REM sleep intrusion, an interesting link, though everything there is self-report.

None of this settles what NDEs are. It does suggest that the "near death" in the name describes the circumstances, not the cause. For the full picture, including distressing NDEs and what changes in people afterwards, see the collection "Near-death experiences: reports, measurement and explanations". As usual, this is a curated cut, not a complete one. The order and the verdicts are ours. :)

1
Must Read
intermediate

Greyson, Bruce · 1983 · Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease

At a GlanceAI

The 16-item Greyson NDE Scale: the instrument almost every later NDE study relies on.

SummaryAI

Starting from 80 typical NDE features, Greyson built a 33-item questionnaire, tested it on 74 experiences, and kept 16 items that formed clinically meaningful clusters. The resulting scale showed high internal consistency and test-retest reliability, correlated strongly with Ring's WCEI, and separated clear NDE claims from questionable ones. A score of 7 or more later became the standard cut-off for counting an experience as an NDE.

The scale that started quantitative academic research on NDEs. Pioneering work.

— ES

Method:AI
Questionnaire construction, item analysis, reliability and validity testing.
Background:AI
Basic psychometrics (reliability, validity).
2
Must Read
intermediate

van Lommel, Pim, van Wees, Ruud, Meyers, Vincent et al. · 2001 · The Lancet

At a GlanceAI

344 resuscitated cardiac patients in ten Dutch hospitals, 18% with NDEs, followed up at 2 and 8 years.

SummaryAI

Van Lommel and colleagues prospectively included 344 consecutive patients resuscitated after cardiac arrest. 62 (18%) reported an NDE and 41 (12%) a core experience. Occurrence was not linked to duration of arrest or unconsciousness, medication, or fear of death, and was more frequent in younger patients. Patients with an NDE were more likely to die within 30 days. Follow-up interviews after 2 and 8 years showed a slow transformation process that differed from survivors without an NDE. The authors argue that a purely physiological cause such as anoxia would make NDEs far more common among clinically dead patients.

A key paper in a prestigious journal that took NDE research to a new level. Careful design. Still, it leaves more questions than answers.

— ES

Method:AI
Prospective multicentre cohort with matched longitudinal follow-up and WCEI scoring.
Background:AI
Ring's WCEI; basic epidemiological study design.
3
Must Read
intermediate
★ Essential

Greyson, Bruce · 2003 · General Hospital Psychiatry

At a GlanceAI

In 1595 cardiac inpatients, NDEs followed 10% of cardiac arrests and 1% of other admissions; objective closeness to death did not differ.

SummaryAI

Greyson surveyed a consecutive sample of 1595 patients on a cardiac inpatient service over 30 months and matched those who reported NDEs with comparison patients. NDEs were reported by 10% of patients with cardiac arrest and 1% of other cardiac patients. Experiencers were younger, more often lost consciousness and reported more prior paranormal experiences, but did not differ in cognitive function, degree of cardiac dysfunction or objective proximity to death.

1595 cardiac patients, matched controls. NDEs in 10% after cardiac arrest and 1% without it. And the groups do NOT differ in objective closeness to death!

— ES

Method:AI
Prospective survey of consecutive admissions with matched comparison group.
Background:AI
Greyson NDE Scale.
4
Worth Reading
intermediate
★ Essential

Charland-Verville, Vanessa, Jourdan, Jean-Pierre, Thonnard, Marie et al. · 2014 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience

At a GlanceAI

NDEs after non-life-threatening events look the same on the Greyson scale as those after coma.

SummaryAI

From 190 reports meeting NDE criteria, Charland-Verville and colleagues compared experiences after coma (140) with "NDE-like" experiences after non-life-threatening events (50). Intensity and content did not differ between the groups, nor across causes of coma. Peacefulness was the most common feature, and only 1% described a negative experience. Retrospective reports showed higher feature frequencies than published prospective data.

NDEs without any threat to life are indistinguishable from "real" ones on the Greyson scale. An inconvenient fact for those who tie NDEs to dying.

— ES

Method:AI
Retrospective survey of self-reported experiences scored with the Greyson NDE Scale.
Background:AI
Greyson NDE Scale.
5
Worth Reading
intermediate

Martial, Charlotte, Cassol, Héléna, Charland-Verville, Vanessa et al. · 2018 · Frontiers in Psychiatry

At a GlanceAI

Fantasy proneness is higher in people with NDE-like experiences, not in those with classical NDEs.

SummaryAI

Martial and colleagues surveyed 228 people, including those with NDEs during a life threat, NDE-like experiences without one, and two control groups, using the Greyson NDE Scale and the Creative Experiences Questionnaire. People with NDE-like experiences scored higher on fantasy proneness than all other groups, while classical experiencers did not differ from controls. Intensity of the experience correlated positively with fantasy proneness.

Fantasy proneness is higher in those whose NDE happened without a threat to life. "Classical" experiencers are just like controls.

— ES

Method:AI
Cross-sectional survey comparing four groups on two questionnaires.
Background:AI
Greyson NDE Scale.
6
Worth Reading
intermediate

Cassol, H., D'Argembeau, A., Charland-Verville, V. et al. · 2019 · Neuroscience of Consciousness

At a GlanceAI

NDE memories become central to identity, and richness of the experience matters more than whether life was at risk.

SummaryAI

Cassol and colleagues asked 71 people with NDEs, with or without a real threat to life, to describe their two main self-defining memories and rate how central each is to their identity. Those who chose the NDE rated it as more central than their other self-defining memories, and the richer the NDE, the more central it was. Real and NDE-like experiencers did not differ, which suggests the content of the experience, not its circumstances, makes it self-defining.

An NDE becomes one of the memories that define a person. And what matters is not whether life was threatened but how rich the experience was.

— ES

Method:AI
Self-defining memory task with the Centrality of Event Scale.
Background:AI
Basic autobiographical memory research.
7
Must Read
intermediate
★ Essential

Timmermann, Christopher, Roseman, Leor, Williams, Luke et al. · 2018 · Frontiers in Psychology

At a GlanceAI

DMT given under placebo control produces experiences that overlap with real NDEs on nearly every feature.

SummaryAI

Thirteen healthy volunteers received DMT and placebo and then completed the Greyson NDE Scale. DMT raised NDE scores significantly compared with placebo, and these scores tracked DMT-induced ego dissolution and mystical-type experience as well as baseline absorption and delusional ideation. Compared with a matched group of people who had actual NDEs, DMT experiences overlapped on nearly all NDE features. The authors call the similarity striking and in need of further study.

DMT produces experiences strikingly similar to NDEs: nearly all features on the Greyson scale overlap with those of actual experiencers. Looks like a beautiful biological explanation of what is going on.

— ES

Method:AI
Within-subjects placebo-controlled drug administration with standard NDE measure and matched comparison.
Background:AI
Greyson NDE Scale; basic psychopharmacology.
8
Skim
intermediate

Kondziella, Daniel, Dreier, Jens P., Olsen, Markus Harboe · 2019 · PeerJ

At a GlanceAI

Crowdsourced survey of 1,034 people: NDEs in 10%, and more often in those reporting REM sleep intrusion.

SummaryAI

Kondziella and colleagues recruited 1,034 lay people from 35 countries online. 10% reported NDEs meeting the Greyson cut-off. People reporting REM sleep intrusion were more likely to have had an NDE (odds ratio 2.85 after adjustment), while age, gender, place of residence, employment and perceived danger did not matter. The link is interesting, but both NDEs and REM intrusion are self-reported in an online sample.

Method:AI
Online crowdsourced survey with multivariate regression.
Background:AI
Greyson NDE Scale; basic regression.